Challenge and Replace Self-Defeating Thoughts

In this exercise, you will:

  • Select three of your self-defeating thoughts that you identified in your self-monitoring activity
  • Ask yourself a series of questions to challenge your thoughts
  • Rewrite the thought so that it is more realistic, hopeful, and reassuring
challenge your thoughts

Now that you’ve practiced recognizing self-defeating thoughts, the next step is to challenge their accuracy and replace them with more helpful perspectives.

ask yourself questions

When you notice a self-defeating thought, try asking yourself:

  • What evidence supports this thought?
  • What evidence contradicts this thought?
  • Does this thought offer hope or solutions?
  • Can I see this situation differently?
  • What action can I take?
  • What advice would I give a friend?
replace self-defeating thoughts

If the result of your thought-challenging is that you find that the thought is self-defeating, you can replace it. Reflect on the thought to create a more helpful thought which should be:

  • Realistic
  • Hopeful
  • Reassuring

download activity to challenge and replace self-defeating thoughts

Select the ‘Download Activity‘ button below to create your plan.  Save the file as a PDF on your computer or phone. If you have a printer, you may print it. If you are completing the activity on your mobile phone, click here for instructions.

upload to Nurse Practitioner or Psychologist

If you are completing the Pain Program with a Certified Goalistics Nurse Practitioner or Psychologist, make sure you submit the PDF using the ‘Upload Activity‘ button below.

understand, identify, challenge and replace, practice

Learning activities